With extra maneuverability? Yeah, this wasn't as close as I thought although it's not quite a chicken vs Apatosaurus scenario.
jhg I suppose you've got a point about the maneuverability, as well as the fairness. As elosha11 wisely said, look from the winner's point of view. Sure they may win, but what's afterwards? Injuries? Disablement? Death?
oldgreengrolar have you tried talking a look from Toxodon's perspective?